menu
Insights

Valuable insights of the auto
industry and service drives.

Data
Service Business
Social Media
Strategies
Targeting
Expectations

Behind the Scenes at TVI MarketPro3: Meet the Tech Team Driving Real Results

Customer Feedback Shaping Service Departments

The Value of the Dealer-Technician Relationship

Dealership Parts and Service: 2 Departments, 1 Team

Digital Solutions Transforming Fixed Operations

The Personality Profile That Promotes Fixed Ops Growth (And the One That Quietly Kills It)

Transparency: The Key to Winning Fixed Ops Customers in 2025

Mastering Dealership Service Customer Conversations

Service Department Revenue: Slow Months

Warranty Work Without the Wait

The Personality Profile That Promotes Fixed Ops Growth (And the One That Quietly Kills It)

In fixed operations, the metrics are unforgiving: labor efficiency, effective labor rate, hours-per-RO, menu adoption, retention, and more. But what determines whether those numbers climb or crater usually isn’t a “service knowledge gap.” It’s a leadership personality gap.

A service department is a high-velocity ecosystem—customers, advisors, technicians, parts, warranties, CSI, production, OEM programs, and a thousand daily micro-decisions. When the person in charge doesn’t have the right traits, they don’t just struggle personally… they subconsciously build a culture that repels accountability, coaching, and improvement.

Fixed-Ops-Growth

Below are traits that consistently show up in business leaders who grow, plus some traits that are a poor fit (even if the person is smart, experienced, and well-liked)—backed by respected leadership research and frameworks.

Personality traits that grow a fixed ops department

1) Humble confidence (low ego + high standards)

The best fixed ops leaders aren’t “soft.” They’re humble and relentless—they can look in the mirror when results are bad and look out the window when results are good.

That paradox is at the heart of Jim Collins’ “Level 5 Leadership”: personal humility + indomitable will. (Jim Collins)

How it shows up in a service lane:

  • -Owns misses without theatrics: “That one’s on me. Here’s what we’re changing.”
  • -Gives credit fast and publicly; upholds standards quietly and consistently.
  • -Doesn’t need to be the hero—needs the store to win.

Why it matters:
Ego makes everything political. Humility makes everything coachable.

2) Emotional intelligence (especially self-control + empathy)

Fixed ops leaders work in an environment of constant friction: upset customers, stressed advisors, comeback conversations, dispatch tension, warranty battles, and more.

Lauren Landry’s conclusion is clear: “Emotional intelligence is one of the most sought-after interpersonal skills in the workplace.” (Harvard Business School)

How it shows up:

  • -Self-awareness
  • -Self-management
  • -Social awareness
  • -Relationship management

3) Learning mindset (coachability + curiosity)

The service department is too complex for “I already know.” The strongest leaders treat problems like a system to be understood, not a person to be blamed.

Amy Edmondson’s psychological safety research shows that teams learn and perform better when people can speak up about issues, mistakes, and risks—without fear of humiliation. (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)

How it shows up:

  • -Invites bad news early: “Where are we breaking the process?”
  • -Asks better questions than they answer.
  • -Treats mistakes as data and still enforces accountability.

4) “Humble, Hungry, Smart” (a shockingly accurate hiring filter)

Patrick Lencioni’s model for an ideal team player is simple:

  • Humble: not status-driven
  • Hungry: self-motivated, driven
  • Smart: people-smart, good judgment in interactions (See Table Here)

How it shows up:

  • -Hungry: pushes the scoreboard forward without being pushed.
  • -Smart: can confront without creating enemies.
  • -Humble: doesn’t protect their image at the expense of the operation.

In fixed ops, this trifecta predicts whether someone will build alignment across advisors, techs, parts, and leadership—or constantly trigger conflict.

5) Leads through changes (urgency without panic)

A growing service department is always changing through inspection adoption, pricing strategy, dispatch discipline, staffing plans, retention workflows, pay plans, and training rhythms.

Kotter’s change framework emphasizes building urgency and aligning people around a clear direction. (Kotter International Inc)

How it shows up:

  • -Creates urgency with purpose (“here’s why it matters”), not fear.
  • -Communicates direction repeatedly.
  • -Builds coalition: advisors + techs + parts + management rowing together.

Personality traits that are a poor fit (especially in fixed ops)

1) Ego-driven / status-protecting (“the alpha”)

This is the leader who must be right, must be seen as the expert, must win every conversation.

Impact:

  • -People hide problems.
  • -Advisors/techs stop bringing ideas.
  • -Processes don’t improve because the truth is filtered.

This is the opposite of the “humility + will” pattern Collins found in top-performing transformations. (Jim Collins)

2) Conflict-avoidant (“the nice guy”)

Niceness is not the same as leadership.

Impact:

  • -Standards become optional.
  • -Top performers resent the lack of consequences.
  • -Culture drifts toward mediocrity.
  • Problems grow. (Harvard Law School)

Fixed ops requires the ability to hold the line and keep relationships intact—an emotional intelligence skill, not a personality preference. 

3) Absent/disengaged leadership (“the autopilot”)

One of the most overlooked warning signs of a struggling department head is a lack of presence. Leaders who are not physically and mentally engaged with their team send an unintended but powerful message: “What’s happening here isn’t my priority.”

Impact:

  • -Advisors feel unsupported during difficult customer conversations.
  • -Technicians feel invisible.
  • -Small process breakdowns compound because no one is watching the system in real time.
  • -Morale drops quietly—and so does performance.

In a service department, presence equals alignment. When the leader is consistently visible, asking questions, reinforcing standards, and coaching in the moment, the department feels supported and accountable at the same time.

4) Lone-wolf mentality (“the hero”)

This leader personally fixes everything… and unknowingly prevents the department from developing.

Impact:

  • -Bottlenecks form around one person.
  • -Coaching doesn’t scale.
  • -Systems remain informal (“ask Jim”) rather than being operationalized.

Kotter’s distinction between aligning people vs. just executing tasks matters here—service growth requires leadership that scales through others. (MBS Accountancy Corporation)

5) Authoritarian / Control-First Leadership (“the dictator”)

What feels like strong leadership in fixed ops can quietly become what Saqib Mansoor Ahmed calls “Authoritarianism Syndrome”—excessive control, distrust of delegation, rigid decision-making, and top-down communication.

In a service department, this shows up as micromanaging advisors, second-guessing technicians, dictating every process detail, and responding to mistakes with punishment instead of coaching.

Impact:

  • -Slower productivity
  • -Lower morale
  • -Reduced creativity
  • -Higher turnover
  • -A leader trapped in daily minutiae instead of driving strategy

Authoritarian leaders believe control ensures perfection. In reality, it creates bottlenecks, burnout, and fear-driven performance. (Authoritarianism Syndrome in Leadership)

The healthiest fixed ops leaders control standards—not people. They build trust, delegate responsibly, focus on outcomes, and coach toward growth.

Check out TVI MarketPro3 for more fixed ops insights.

Let's get moving. Get your customized marketing plan today.

Thank You! A representative will reach out to you shortly!
Next
Captcha
Submit

View All

Follow Us

© 2026 TVI-MarketPro3 | Privacy Policy

Sign up for email updates