menu
Insights

Fuel your marketing engine
with the TVI MarketPro3 Blog

Subscribe to our blog!


Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 101

Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 101

Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 101

Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 101

Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 101

Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 101

Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 101
Advertising
Automotive
Business
Fixed Operations
Marketing
Small Business
Bonus Content

Customer Pay Labor Rates Mistakes

Setting the right labor rates is essential for a dealership’s service department's profitability. Still, many dealerships fall into common pricing traps that cost them revenue, fail to justify the value of dealership service, and drive customers to independent repair shops. Nick Shaffer, Vice President of Sales at TVI MarketPro3, highlights key mistakes dealerships make when pricing customer pay labor rates—and how to fix them. Inconsistent or Misaligned Pricing: Keep Your Rates Aligned with Market Trends One of the most significant issues to fix is inconsistent or misaligned pricing. Many dealerships fail to adjust labor rates regularly based on inflation, technician wages, and market competition. Some mistakenly charge a flat rate for all services, meaning complex diagnostics are billed at the same rate as simple maintenance work, despite requiring more expertise and time. Another common misstep is failing to differentiate pricing by technician skill level. A master technician performing an intricate repair should not be billed at the same rate as an entry-level tech handling an oil change. Without structured labor rate tiers, dealerships risk undercharging for high-value services and losing revenue. Failing to Conduct Competitive Market Analysis: Know Your Competition Another frequent mistake is failing to conduct a competitive market analysis. Some dealerships set rates too high, deterring customers, while others underprice their labor, leaving potential profits on the table. Many overlook how their pricing compares to that of nearby independent repair shops, not realizing that customers often weigh dealership service costs against local mechanics. Additionally, national chains like Firestone and Pep Boys offer competitive labor rates, and without proper benchmarking, dealerships may struggle to justify their pricing. To remain competitive, dealerships must regularly analyze local market trends, compare labor rates with competitors, and communicate why their service is worth a premium—such as offering factory-trained technicians, OEM parts, and warranty-backed repairs. Lack of Transparency: Build Trust with Clear Pricing Transparency is another critical factor. Customers are more price-conscious than ever, and unexpected fees or unclear pricing can quickly erode trust. A common pitfall is failing to explain labor costs upfront. Customers who don’t understand what they’re paying for often perceive dealership pricing as excessive. Hidden fees or surprise charges at checkout further damage relationships and can lead to negative reviews. Service advisors should clearly break down labor charges, offer digital inspections with photos or videos to justify services, and reinforce the value of dealership service. Inefficient Technician Utilization: Maximize Billable Hours Another area where dealerships lose money is inefficient technician utilization. Many shops waste highly skilled technicians on basic services instead of reserving master technicians for jobs that justify their expertise. This underbilling leads to lost revenue opportunities. Additionally, failing to monitor technician efficiency results in wasted labor hours. Service departments should use dispatching software to assign jobs based on skill level, minimize "comebacks" by ensuring thorough repairs the first time, and track technician productivity to optimize billable hours. Failing to Communicate Value: Demonstrate Why Dealership Service is Worth It A major challenge for many dealerships is communicating value to customers. Many customers assume dealership service departments charge higher rates without offering additional benefits. If a dealership does not clearly highlight its advantages, such as factory-trained technicians, OEM parts, and warranty-backed service, customers may see no reason to choose it over an independent mechanic. Bundling services can also help improve perceived value. Instead of pricing everything à la carte, dealerships can create package deals. For example, an oil change, tire rotation, and multi-point inspection can be offered at a discounted labor rate, or a brake job that includes pads, rotors, and a brake fluid flush can be priced as a value package. This approach makes labor costs feel more reasonable and can increase customer retention. Weak Labor Rate Negotiation Strategy: Avoid Unnecessary Discounts A weak labor rate negotiation strategy is another common mistake. Some service advisors discount labor too aggressively to close a sale, directly cutting into dealership profitability. Without a structured pricing strategy, discounts can become excessive and unpredictable. Instead of across-the-board reductions, dealerships should implement targeted discounts. Offering loyalty discounts for repeat customers or a small labor discount on significant repairs—such as "spend $500, get 10% off labor"—can encourage customer retention while protecting margins. Advisors should also be trained to upsell high-margin services, such as fluid flushes and alignments, without relying on deep discounts. Conclusion: Optimize Your Labor Rate Strategy for Success Ultimately, a strategic approach to labor rates is key to maximizing profitability while maintaining customer trust. Dealerships can avoid pricing mistakes by implementing tiered labor rates that reflect job complexity and technician skill, conducting regular competitive market analysis, improving transparency through clear pricing explanations and digital inspections, bundling services to enhance perceived value, optimizing technician utilization, and training advisors to upsell effectively without excessive discounts. If price increases are necessary, dealerships should justify them by adding value, such as extended labor warranties, complimentary car washes, shuttle services, or loaner vehicles for significant repairs. By refining their labor rate strategy, dealerships can boost revenue, strengthen customer relationships, and maintain a competitive edge in an increasingly price-sensitive market. Check out TVI MarketPro3 for valuable fixed ops insights.

Continue Reading


Notice: Trying to get property 'name' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 202


Notice: Trying to get property 'count' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 204
Article(s)


Notice: Trying to get property 'term_id' of non-object in /var/www/blog/wp-content/themes/tvi-mp3-wp-theme/index.php on line 212

View All

Follow Us

© 2025 TVI-MarketPro3 | Privacy Policy

Sign up for email updates